Bourbon 2016

Best Bourbon - 2016


The Fifty Best Bourbon Tasting of 2016


The Tasting:
The Fifty Best held a “blind” tasting of 20 bourbon whiskies with a panel of 15 judges. Strict tasting rules were applied. The order of service was established beforehand by lottery. The bourbons were poured into fresh glasses from new sealed bottles, and served at slightly above room temperature. Each of the bourbons were evaluated and scored separately. Only ice water, neutral unflavored crackers and chips were available to cleanse the palate.

The judges wrote down their impressions of each product on score sheets. The scoring was done on a 5-point system, with 5 as the best. Double-Gold, Gold and Silver medals are awarded according to a set range of final point scores received from the judges. There were no bronze medals awarded for this tasting. The tasting notes that follow are summaries of the judges’ opinions, with all replicated commentary eliminated. The states of origin are identified for each brand.


Spirit of America
86° proof  (Indiana)

Nose: Dried figs, subtle dried fruit, light butterscotch, vanilla, pear, green apple, dandelion, blossoms, mint, dinner mints, grass, peppery, pecan, wheat, oak, clean, fresh.
Palate: Fudge, caramel, vanilla, pineapple, tropical fruit, strawberry, sultana, pear, toasted coconut, dried fruit, sherry, wild flowers, blossom, subtle wheat, hay, walnut, almond, licorice, mint, nutmeg, peppery, spicy, tobacco, leather, well balanced.
Finish: Fruity, honey, almond, mint, clove, spicy, salty, smooth, soft, elegant.

Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal

   Spirit of America Bourbon

Buffalo Trace
90° proof  (Kentucky)

Nose: Caramel, butterscotch, sweet corn, green apple, sour apple, pear, cherry, persimmon, pineapple, peaches, dried apricots, coconut, honeysuckle, tea leaves, green leaves, grassy, mint, tarragon, hay, oak.
Palate: Caramel, toffee, molasses, buttery, vanilla, citrus, orange, marmalade, fruit preserves, cherry cobbler, apple peel, apple, sweet grains, dates, marzipan, sherry, rose petals, mint, nutmeg, pepper, pine, clean, delicate.
Finish: Apple, hazelnut, toast, tea, mint, spicy, oak, nice, easy.

Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal

Buffalo Trace Bourbon

Hudson Baby Bourbon
92° proof  (New York)

Nose: Caramel, cream, vanilla, honey, molasses, sugar cane, demerara, toffee, dried dark fruit, sherry, popcorn, toast, hay, grass, mint, peppermint, rye, nutty, new oak, tobacco, pipe tobacco, leather.
Palate: Toffee, caramel, butterscotch, buttery, vanilla, honey, molasses, dried fruit, prune, coconut, walnut, oak, peppermint, patchouli, clove, cinnamon, spice, white pepper, smoky, tannins, smooth.
Finish: Coffee, caramel, maple, creamy, licorice, peppermint, pepper, woody, leather, well balanced, smooth, flavorful.

Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal

Hudson Baby Bourbon

1792 Small Batch
93.75° proof  (Kentucky)

Nose: Dark chocolate, toffee, butterscotch candy, butter, cream, vanilla, honey, sugarcane, subtle molasses, papaya, orange, eucalyptus, rose petals, hay, pine, oak.
Palate: Toffee, butterscotch, buttery, caramel, candy corn, creamy, vanilla, honey, green apple, orange, peach, pear, coconut, walnut, elderflower, sweet tea, licorice, nutmeg, spice, mint, grass, pine, oak, smoky, smooth, bright, nicely done.
Finish: Nice spice, floral, peppery, hazelnut, nutty, wood, smooth.

Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal

1792 Small Batch Bourbon

High West American Prairie
92° proof  (Utah)

Nose: Butterscotch, caramel, toffee, vanilla, cane sugar, toasted coconut, honey, cola, dates, dried prunes, sherry, licorice, hay, banana leaf, grass, tea leaves, oak.
Palate: Toffee, caramel, cola, honey, toasted sugar, sugarcane, orange, orange zest, apple, dried prunes, dried fruit, hazelnut, nuts, cinnamon, allspice, coriander, clove, mint, eucalyptus, grass, oak, cognac notes, woody, flavorful, balanced, delicate, elegant.
Finish: Fruity, apple peel, vanilla cream, slight spice, salty, minty, pine, woody, leather, flavorful.

Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal

High West American Prairie Bourbon


Colorado Gold Straight Bourbon Whiskey
90° proof  (Colorado)

Nose: Toffee, caramel, chocolate, clotted cream, toasted sugar, molasses, honey, tropical fruit, banana, pineapple, ripe fruits, dried fruit, marzipan, blossom, hibiscus, floral, herbal, oloroso, spice, popcorn, hay, oak.
Palate: Chocolate, vanilla, caramel, creamy, sugarcane, honey, sweet corn, coconut, dried figs, dates, raisins, sherry, biscuit, hazelnut, coffee, cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, pepper, pipe tobacco, nice wood.
Finish: Toffee, caramel, vanilla, brown sugar, coconut, nutty, coffee, pepper, spicy, woody, smooth.

Gold Medal
Gold medal

Colorado Gold Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Broken Bell
90° proof  (Minnesota)

Nose: Raisins, dates, dried fruit, pineapple, banana pudding, vanilla custard, vanilla, caramel, butterscotch, nougat, honey, molasses, Graham cracker, maple syrup, corn, blossom, hay, green leaves, grass, pine, oak.
Palate: Butterscotch, toffee, caramel, cream, honeycomb, honey, orange marmalade, orange peel, lemony, citrus, strawberry, apricot, cantaloupe, banana, coconut, roasted nuts, almond, licorice, rose, tea leaves, mint, grass, pine, pepper, black pepper, light spice, oak.
Finish: Apple peel, fruity, buttery, licorice, walnut, clove, spicy, oak, smooth, soft.

Gold Medal
Gold medal

Broken Bell Bourbon

Paddleford Creek
83° proof  (Minnesota)

Nose: Chocolate, molasses, butterscotch, vanilla, buttermilk, banana, lemon, citrus, green apple, apple peel, dried fruit, maple, licorice, sambuca, walnut, nutmeg, pine, earthy.
Palate: Toffee, caramel, crème brûlée, creamy, buttermilk, coconut, corn, honeysuckle, apricot, pear, ginger, eucalyptus, mint, licorice, tea, hay, oak, ultra-light, silky, smooth.
Finish: Buttery, creamy, candy corn, floral, cinnamon, spicy, oak, smooth, elegant.

Gold Medal
Gold medal

Paddleford Creek Bourbon

Beanball Small Batch Bourbon
90° proof  (New York)

Nose: Caramel, creamy, vanilla, brown sugar, molasses, treacle, popcorn jellybean, honey, banana, bananas foster, coconut, dried fruit, apple brandy, lavender, hay, rye, tobacco, leather, pine, oak.
Palate: Honey, cane sugar, brown sugar, vanilla, creamy, butterscotch, toffee, caramel corn, gulab jamun, banana, orange peel, sultana, sherry, mint, elegant smoke, oak, soft.
Finish: Fruity, apple peel, honey, marzipan, licorice, mint, tea, spicy, leather, smooth, beautifully balanced.

Gold Medal
Gold medal

Beanball Small Batch Bourbon

Rebel Yell Kentucky Straight Bourbon
80° proof  (Kentucky)

Nose: Caramel, toffee, whipped cream, cane sugar, honey, vanilla, pound cake, toasted oats, coconut, pecan, pineapple, apple, lemon, citrus, green tea, grassy, tobacco, oak, leather.
Palate: Toffee, caramel, Werther's Original, vanilla, cream, honey, brown sugar, sweet corn, biscuit, coconut, pecan, apple, pear, banana, berry notes, lemon, lemon peel, citrus, green tea, light spice, clove, nutmeg, walnut, young wood, oak, very correct.
Finish: Vanilla, banana, citrus, marzipan, pecan, cinnamon, oak, wood notes, mellow, smooth, elegant.

Gold Medal
Gold medal

Rebel Yell Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Black Dirt
90° proof  (New York)

Nose: Honey, maple, lemon zest, tea, tea leaves, black tea, wormwood, sandalwood, patchouli, sage, nutmeg, nutty, pine, woody, leather.
Palate: Toffee, caramel, vanilla, honey, Golden Grahams, molasses, maple, sherry, almond, chamomile, elderflower, peppermint, black tea leaves, hazelnut, rye, oak.
Finish: Dark sugar, pear, nutmeg, allspice, spicy, green tea, eucalyptus, touch of wood, well balanced, bold, beautiful.

Gold Medal
Gold medal

Black Dirt Bourbon

Copper Fiddle
92° proof  (Illinois)

Nose: Caramel, butterscotch, cream, custard, chocolate, nutella, coconut, hazelnut, fruitcake, dried fruit, brown sugar, maple syrup, molasses, mole sauce, toast, grain, coffee, nutty, charcoal, smoky, pine, leather.
Palate: Butterscotch, toffee, fudge, Cracker Jack, molasses, vanilla, vanilla custard, dates, coconut, pear, apricot, fruitcake, marzipan, licorice, hay, clove, allspice, mixed spices, peppery, coffee, smoky, tobacco, oak, full flavored, balanced, pleasant.
Finish: Honey, maple, chocolate, nutty, spicy, smoke, toast, oak, smooth, velvety, balanced.

Gold Medal
Gold medal

Copper Fiddle Bourbon

Wyoming Whiskey
88° proof  (Wyoming)

Nose: Honey, vanilla, clotted cream, sugarcane, molasses, maple, toffee, faint caramel, coconut, banana, pineapple, dried apricot, fruity, citrus, green tea, grassy, hay, cinnamon.
Palate: Vanilla, honey, molasses, caramel, toffee notes, banana, coconut, raisins, apple, pear, sweet potato, sweet sherry, floral, almond, peppermint, eucalyptus, tea leaves, tobacco, pepper, oak.
Finish: Caramel, honey, faint coconut, cinnamon, peppery, leather, oak, clean, smooth.

Gold Medal
Gold medal

Wyoming Small Batch Bourbon Whiskey

Widow Jane
91° proof  (New York)

Nose: Toffee, chocolate, butterscotch, brown sugar, honey, honey oat, vanilla, fruitcake, dried fruit, corn, nutmeg, tobacco, apple peel, citrus, floral, cut grass, hay, pine, wood barrel, oak.
Palate: Caramel, butterscotch, chocolate notes, creamy, vanilla, honey, banana, banana peel, fresh coconut, orange, prune, apple, elderflower, musk, licorice, anise, clove, mint, eucalyptus, tarragon, allspice, coffee, pepper, wood, leather.
Finish: Honey, creamy, almond, licorice, eucalyptus, tea, pepper, spicy, woody.

Gold Medal
Gold medal

Widow Jane Bourbon

Jimmy's Texas Bourbon
90° proof  (Texas)

Nose: Toffee, vanilla, brown sugar, honey, caramel apple, dried fruit, banana bread, ripe banana, pear, grape, citrus, blossom, floral, hay, tea, cinnamon, clove, nutty.
Palate: Chocolate, toffee, molasses, vanilla, caramel, creamy, honey, fig, dates, banana, sherry, flowers, lavender, almond, walnut, clove, eucalyptus, white pepper, wheat, toast, smoky, woody, oak, smooth, balanced.
Finish: Lemon peel, ginger, mint, eucalyptus, spicy, wood, oak, well balanced, smooth.

Gold Medal
Gold medal

Jimmy's Texas Bourbon

J. Henry & Sons
92 proof 5 yr aged Bourbon

92° proof  (Wisconsin)

Nose: Banana, pineapple, orange, tropical fruit, butterscotch, toffee, honey, chocolate, maple, green leaves, grass, clove, oak, lovely applewood.
Palate: Toffee, butterscotch, chocolate, creamy, vanilla, treacle, maple, ripe banana, orange zest, marmalade, apple, blossoms, cinnamon, tarragon, tea leaves, green leaves, tobacco, pepper, oak, soft, elegant.
Finish: Citrus, maple, nutty, salty, tarragon, spicy, woody, oak.

Gold Medal
Gold medal

J. Henry & Sons 5 yr old 92 proof Bourbon

J. Henry & Sons
5 yr old Cask Strength Patton Road Reserve Bourbon

127° proof  (Wisconsin)

Nose: Butterscotch, caramel, toffee, buttery, cream, honey, vanilla, cola, plum, apricot, peach, citrus, floral, sherry notes, cinnamon, green leaves, toast, woody.
Palate: Butterscotch, toffee, caramel, creamy, vanilla, banana, sweet corn, cherry, sultana, sour peach, citrus, bright mint, spearmint, eucalyptus, peppery, cinnamon, spicy, mineral, smooth.
Finish: Fruity, spicy, clove, pine.

Gold Medal
Gold medal

J. Henry & Sons 5 yr old Cask Strength Patton Road Reserve Bourbon


Black Fly
(New York)

Nose: Caramel, butterscotch, toffee, molasses, treacle, vanilla, light maple, raisins, dried fruit, agave, grass, moss, pine, floral, hay, tobacco, leather, clove, oak.
Palate: Melted caramel, butterscotch, fudge, chocolate, cocoa, honey, clover honey, sugarcane, banana, green apple, dates, almond, marzipan, licorice, lavender, patchouli, wintergreen, spearmint, sage, tea leaves, woody, oak, smoke, leather.
Finish: Cocoa, brown sugar, fruity, floral, tea, spicy.

Silver Medal
Silver medal

Black Fly Bourbon

Better Days Wine Barrel Finished Bourbon

Nose: Cane sugar, honey, molasses, maple syrup, caramel, candy corn, butterscotch, ripe banana, banana peel, carob, raisins, mint, green leaves, grass, moss, pine, spice, nutmeg, smoky.
Palate: Vanilla, maple syrup, molasses, pear, citrus, raisins, prune, dates, sherry, toast, coffee, walnut, nutty, floral, light herbal, mint, peppermint, clove, eucalyptus, grassy, sweet wood, pine, tannic, white pepper, cayenne, spice, has character.
Finish: Vanilla, caramel, rose, mint, spicy, sour dough, leather.

Silver Medal
Silver medal

Better Days Wine Barrel Finished Bourbon

Orange County Distillery Bourbon
90° proof  (New York)

Nose: Molasses, toffee, raw chestnuts, toast, burnt coconut, roasted filberts, tobacco, tea, sage, green apple, green leaves, wet grass, new wood, pine, oak, moss, earth, leather.
Palate: Toffee, fudge, caramel, molasses, creamy, sugarcane, multicolored corn, cereal, herbal, licorice, tea leaves, grass, peppermint, cinnamon, tobacco, tannic, pine, oak, cedar, pepper, leather.
Finish: Chocolate, banana, herbal, mint, green grass, salty, woody, oak, gentle.

Silver Medal
Silver medal

Orange County Distillery Bourbon




Disclaimer: This section of the website is intended for visitors 21 years of age and older.
If you are not of legal drinking age, please exit by clicking here.

Please drink responsibly!

Comments or questions welcome, please e-mail to:


Comments and Suggestions:

Thu. September 28, 2017 12:36 AM - by:
I like Widow Jane: Toffee, chocolate, butterscotch, brown sugar, honey, honey oat, vanilla, fruitcake, dried fruit, corn, nutmeg, tobacco, apple peel, citrus, floral, cut grass, hay, pine, wood barrel, oak. internet speed test

Add a comment or suggestion to this list.
*The following fields are required and must be filled in.
Email (for verification purposes only, will not be displayed):

Sign up for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.

Fifty Best > Spirits Archive > Bourbon 2016
©        home   |  Advertise   |  Privacy   |  Awards   |  Legal   |  About   |  Logos   |  Sign-Up   |  Contact       HappyViper