Domestic Vodka
 

Best Domestic Vodka

 

The Fifty Best Domestic Vodka Tasting 2023


The Fifty Best held a “blind” tasting of 15 American-made unflavored craft vodkas with ten members of our spirits judging panel. The order of service was established beforehand by lottery. Strict tasting rules were applied. The vodkas were poured into fresh glasses from new sealed bottles, and served at slightly above room temperature. Only ice water, neutral unflavored crackers and chips were available to cleanse the palate.

The judges wrote down their impressions of each product on score sheets. The scoring was done on a 5-point system, with 5 as the highest. Double-Gold, Gold and Silver medals are awarded according to a set range of final point scores received from the judges. There were no Bronze medals awarded for this tasting. Medals are provided based entirely on merit and only to products judged worthy of such award.

The tasting notes that follow are summaries of the judges’ opinions, with all replicated commentary eliminated. The distilleries, states of origin and other tidbits are identified for each brand. All vodkas are 80° proof, except when indicated. Clicking on the brands' names will link to their websites.


DOUBLE-GOLD MEDAL WINNERS


Atlanta Vodka
(Atlanta Distillery, GA)
Distilled from apples.

Nose: Butterscotch candy, Oreo filling, cream, pastry dough, bread, honey, apple, cider, fermenting fruit, potato peel, vegetal, herbal, delicate.
Palate: Butterscotch candy, toffee, buttery, chocolate, cocoa nibs, vanilla, cane sugar, mixed fruits, citrus, citrus oils, anise, ripe grass, pink peppercorn, wet stone, slate, creamy mouthfeel, round, crisp, vibrant, would make a great martini, lovely.
Finish: Cocoa, covered strawberries, wheat, grain, mint, peppery, balanced, super smooth, intense, lively, flavorful, tasty, easy drinking.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal


   Atlanta Vodka


Yacht Life Vodka
(Sun Coast Loaded Cannon Distilled Spirits, FL)
Distilled from wheat.

Nose: Vanilla, pronounced cream, caramel, pastry dough, grain, wet grain, banana, Meyer lemon, fresh juniper, vegetal, herbal, mossy, minerals, earthy, funky, wood barrel.
Palate: Melon, apple, lemony, lemon zest, banana, cereal grains, Cheerios, popcorn, roasted cashews, potato skin, anise, grassy, moss, herbal, almond oil, black pepper, mineral, stone, Calvados flavor, whiskey-like, well balanced, smooth, clean, crisp, rich, tasty.
Finish: Apple, lemon lingers, citrus, tropical fruit, herbal, grassy, subtle spice, peppery, black pepper, smooth, clean, crisp, vibrant for a martini, stays rich, flavorful, tasty.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal


Yacht Life Vodka


The Calistoga Depot 1868 Vodka
(The Calistoga Depot Distillery 1868, CA)
Distilled from grain.

Nose: Vanilla, cocoa, sweet corn, grain, pastry dough, bread, agave notes, cactus, light lemon, coffee, coffee grinds, earthy, mineral, wet stone, slight funk.
Palate: Vanilla, cocoa, cocoa nibs, powdered sugar, sweet pastry, bread, lemon/lime, citrus, mint, peppery, earthy, mineral, creamy mouthfeel, silky.
Finish: Lemony, citrus lingers, a bit of mint, lingering pastry dough, pink peppercorn, pepper, balanced, complex flavors, flavorful, tasty, smooth, clean, rich, fun.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal


The Calistoga Depot 1868 Vodka


Mutiny Island Vodka
(Sion Farm Distillery, St. Croix, USVI)
Distilled from breadfruit.

Nose: Cookie dough, pastry dough, bread, grain, vanilla, faint anise, almond, white peppercorn, subtle black pepper, clean.
Palate: Vanilla, toffee, cocoa, Confectioners’ sugar, baking cookies, dough, pastry dough, pizza dough, bread, potato, French fries, carrot, vegetal, almond oil, white pepper, multiple hot peppers, mineral, balanced, rich, creamy, vibrant, tasty.
Finish: Powdered sugar, rye, pepper, white pepper, mineral, viscous, clean, soft, very approachable, lively.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal


Mutiny Island Vodka


GOLD MEDAL WINNERS

OVO Vodka
(FL)
Distilled from corn.

Nose: Bread, almond, nutty, anise, citrus notes, peppery, musty, light mineral, clean, crisp.
Palate: Vanilla, Confectioners’ sugar, lemon cream, lemon verbena, mint, ouzo, potato skins, light carrot, cocoa, coffee, white peppercorn, mossy, wet stone, wood barrel, nicely blended flavors, clean, delicate, round, creamy, vibrant.
Finish: Grain, subtle mint, lingering black pepper, dusty, bottled spring water, clean, smooth, mellow, creamy, zesty, intriguing, great.


Gold Medal
Gold medal


OVO Vodka


Knee-High Vodka
80 Proof

(Knee-High Distilling, IA)
Distilled from corn.

Nose: Melon, subtle mint, Confectioners’ sugar, pastry, bread crust, coconut husk, faint licorice, cigar box.
Palate: Vanilla, Confectioners’ sugar, powdered sugar, fermented fruit, rye, marbled rye, bread, grain, mossy, grassy, complex, balanced, layers of flavor, smooth, creamy, rich, silky.
Finish: Melon, mint, powdered sugar, almond oil, white peppercorn, bright to soft progression, creamy, tasty, a vodka for the fall, would make a fun cocktail.


Gold Medal
Gold medal


Knee-High Vodka 80 Proof


YoCo Vodka
(KY/TN)
Distilled from corn.

Nose: Sweet corn, breakfast cereal, grain, sweet anise up front, grassy note, tobacco, mineral, wet stone, fresh linen, clean.
Palate: Creamy sweet corn, light vanilla, rich grain, bread, potato, lemon zest, citrus, floral petals, herbal, almond oil, slightly spicy, ultrasmooth throughout, clean, delicate, creamy, tasty, classic.
Finish: Pastry dough, powdered sugar, rye notes, slightly peppery, earth, stone, clean, soft, tasty, easy drinking.


Gold Medal
Gold medal


YoCo Vodka


High Rock Vodka
(Sugarlands Distilling Co., TN)
Distilled from corn.

Nose: Lemon, citrus, grain, pastry, subtle anise, distant nuts, wet stones, a hint of magnesium, mineral, lake water, pond, soft, rich.
Palate: Dark cherry, cocoa, vanilla, dough, bread, rye, anise, white peppercorn, pepper bite, intense minerals, red slate, magnesium, creamy mouthfeel, soft flavors, clean, mellow.
Finish: Birthday cake, black pepper, spices, sweetness, long mineral finish, persistent heat, zesty, nice, rich, tasty.


Gold Medal
Gold medal


High Rock Vodka


Blue Shark Vodka
(NC)
Distilled from grain.

Nose: Dough, pastry flakes, light corn, subtle citrus, herbaceous, mossy, black pepper, mineral, fresh water, clean, neutral.
Palate: Vanilla, lime skin, dried lime skin, anise, grassy, nuts, white pepper, black pepper, mineral stones, mineral, well balanced, bright, very subtle, soft, creamy.
Finish: Vanilla, cream, cocoa note, Confectioners’ sugar, dried lime skin, lemon lingers, lightly grassy, hibiscus, peppery, limestone, mineral, fresh, soft, vibrant, zesty, elegant, great.


Gold Medal
Gold medal


Blue Shark Vodka


Cylinder Ultra-Premium Vodka
(The Corebev Group, CT)
Distilled from corn. Gluten free.

Nose: Vanilla, cocoa, wheat, grain, herbal, juniper, potato, wet potato, coffee, clay, mineral, stone, wet stone, clean laundry.
Palate: Vanilla, lemon peel, lemon zest, green plantain, mint, grain, coffee, peppery, spicy, mineral, creamy mouthfeel, mellow start, bold, intense, clean, crisp.
Finish: Corn, citrus, coffee notes, gentle spice, toasty, mineral, limestone, some sweetness, clean, bright, bold, intense, rich.


Gold Medal
Gold medal


Cylinder Ultra-Premium Vodka


SILVER MEDAL WINNERS

Vanishing Vodka
(Weiss Distilling, MI)
Distilled from grain.

Nose: Crème brûlée, wild flowers, rye, grain, faint anise, grassy, forest greens, mineral oil, minerals, rainstorm, crisp.
Palate: Vanilla cream, dough, cherry, berries, lemon, anise, vegetal, mint, herbal, rye, seeds, nuts, coffee, minerals, white peppercorn, white pepper, light mineral, rich, creamy.
Finish: Fruit cornucopia, fruit punch, lingering lemon, grassy, spice, white peppercorn, white pepper, powdery, evens out, clean, soft, rich, elegant.


Silver Medal
Silver medal


Vanishing Vodka


Herbesco Smooth Vodka
(MA)
Distilled from grain.

Nose: Melon rind, light papaya, green peppers, potato skin, vegetal, dough, puff pastry, fauna, earth, dusty, minerals, clean.
Palate: Melon, cantaloupe, crenshaw melon, lemon, lemon zest, citrus, berry, cotton candy, potato, corn, peppery, earthiness, mineral, creamy mouthfeel, complex, assertive, tasty.
Finish: Melon, lingering lemon, citrus, spice rack, oregano, peppery, mushroomy, earth, touch of smoke, heat, complex, nice, smooth, clean, crisp, zesty, tasty.


Silver Medal
Silver medal


Herbesco Smooth Vodka


Knee-High Vodka
100 Proof

(Knee-High Distilling, IA)
Distilled from corn.

Nose: Toffee, honeydew, pastry dough, bread, potato skin, rye, flowery, light anise, white pepper, laundry hanging outside, garden after rainfall, clean, crisp, lively.
Palate: Vanilla, whipped cream, pastry dough, herbal bread, rye, grain, almond, nutty, light lemon note, pepper, spicy, mineral, dusty, slate, clean, high proof.
Finish: Fruity, some citrus, Amarula-like, nutty, peppery, lingering black pepper, minerals, creamy, smooth, high proof, assertive, balanced heat, bite on finish, great for cocktails.


Silver Medal
Silver medal


Knee-High Vodka 100 Proof


Chakra Vodka
(Carefree Spirits Distillery, AZ)
Distilled from grain.

Nose: Vanilla, dough, bread, grain, root vegetable, coffee, mineral, stone, clean.
Palate: Vanilla, sweet cane, sweet grain, bread, strong cocoa note, carrot, olives, white peppercorn, minerals, dusty, balanced, soft, creamy, mixable, easy to drink.
Finish: Vanilla ice cream, vanilla, whipped cream, cane sugar, touch of citrus, coffee notes, white pepper, peppery, saline, minerals, stone, wet stone, smooth.


Silver Medal
Silver medal


Chakra Vodka


Wild Leap Vodka
(GA)
Distilled from yellow corn.

Nose: Grain, powdered sugar, woody, clean sheets, crisp, mild, delicate.
Palate: Vanilla, dough, Confectioners’ sugar, lemon cream, applesauce, anise, peach pit, white pepper, light peppercorn, pine, cedar notes, subtle with a bang, soft, super smooth, creamy, savory.
Finish: Cocoa, lingering powdered sugar, citrus echoes, grassy, white peppercorn, peppery, mineral, wet stone, fresh, nice, creamy, good for a chocolate martini.


Silver Medal
Silver medal


Wild Leap Vodka

 

 


 

Vodka's illustrious history in the Old World is well known. What about American-made vodkas? Whenever a new distillery opens its doors, it’s vodka that they usually produce first, since vodka is made from simple ingredients and doesn’t require a complicated distillation process or barrel aging. And now there are over 1,500 brands of unflavored American vodkas – currently being produced by micro-distillers all across the country.

Much like craft brewers and vintners, the entrepreneurial master distillers proudly use local grains (or potatoes, corn, grapes, sugarcane, apples, etc.) and local water sources to produce their small batch craft vodkas. These particular ingredients (as well as distillation methods) impart distinctive character and flavors to the finished products. The water sources and the soil from which the base ingredients are grown adds an extra emphasis of "terroir" to the individuality of these artisanal spirits. Anyone who still believes that vodka is an odorless, tasteless clear spirit hasn't tried American-made artisanal craft vodkas.

 

 

Disclaimer: This section of the website is intended for visitors 21 years of age and older.
If you are not of legal drinking age, please exit by clicking here.


Please drink responsibly!